MicrostockGroup Sponsors


Author Topic: Disastrous performance of FT/AS in November  (Read 11788 times)

0 Members and 1 Guest are viewing this topic.

« on: November 17, 2017, 11:57 »
0
I know how some of you hate this kind of topics, but this one appears to be out of an ordinary one (at least for me), and I'm on a verge of freaking out: my sales at Fotolia/Adobe Stock have almost stopped in November, with a projected drop in sales vs October by -20% (or considerably more if the trend remains) and could be my worst ever month in 2.5 years (port of close to 2K images). As you can see, in my case fluctuations month to month with FT/AS are common, but November is something special (remember, we're in 17 November, with less than 10 working days left in this month).

Capture" border="0

Does anybody have a similar situation?


steheap

  • Author of best selling "Get Started in Stock"

« Reply #1 on: November 17, 2017, 12:02 »
+5
Sorry - normal month for me - perhaps even a bit better. And to add to your misery, we have Thanksgiving in the US next week so a loss of good buying days from that holiday.

Steve

« Reply #2 on: November 17, 2017, 12:58 »
0
Sorry - normal month for me - perhaps even a bit better. And to add to your misery, we have Thanksgiving in the US next week so a loss of good buying days from that holiday.

Steve

Thanks, Steve. Could explain in part such a drop, since this is also a case for me with Shutterstock. I somehow expected November to be on par with October which historically is my best-performing month.

« Reply #3 on: November 17, 2017, 13:28 »
+1
Why don't you use your weekly rank to understand if it is only you or a global trend? That's one thing I like about FT.
Personally, I noticed that I'm selling ~20% more than a year ago. Despite the growth, my weekly rank keeps on fluctuating around the same values. This November is no different.
Based on this indicator, I can say that, yes, competition is tougher!

« Reply #4 on: November 17, 2017, 15:09 »
+2
Different story for me.
I was only doing video and I was doing fine with Fotolia: I had not a lot, but my regular 10-15 uploads per month, average $28 each, but sometimes the odd $70, let's say 400-600 per month.
not really increasing, in spite of constant uploading, but it was OK.
Then I had the stupid idea of starting to upload also photo (about 3 months ago)...
Guess what, I still had the same number of uploads, but they were all photos, fro ridiculous amounts, so my income went from $400-600 a month o some stupid $10-15 from one day to the next.
So this week I went like crazy deleting all my photo portfolio, one by one, and guess what?
I finally had a video sale yesterday and another one today

« Reply #5 on: November 17, 2017, 16:10 »
+2
The short answer is no, I don't, but you want to compare this November with last November, not with October 2017.

If you don't have seasonal images, you might see a drop as this is the peak time of year for seasonal downloads - I just checked my last 200 sales on FT/Adobe and 39% were seasonal; SS was a bit lower this year at 33% of the total.

I have generally seen November be the peak sales month for my portfolio (started doing this in fall 2004)

« Reply #6 on: November 17, 2017, 16:48 »
0
I experienced some periods in the last couple of months when sales just came to a standstill for a few days this month luckily for me is more normal now it seems. I slipped down the ranking a long way.....luck or algorithm change who knows?

« Reply #7 on: November 17, 2017, 20:30 »
0
Different story for me.
I was only doing video and I was doing fine with Fotolia: I had not a lot, but my regular 10-15 uploads per month, average $28 each, but sometimes the odd $70, let's say 400-600 per month.
not really increasing, in spite of constant uploading, but it was OK.
Then I had the stupid idea of starting to upload also photo (about 3 months ago)...
Guess what, I still had the same number of uploads, but they were all photos, fro ridiculous amounts, so my income went from $400-600 a month o some stupid $10-15 from one day to the next.
So this week I went like crazy deleting all my photo portfolio, one by one, and guess what?
I finally had a video sale yesterday and another one today

I readed already this topic, and I am worry about it, I am a video principally, but I also uploaded some photos, an even having more than 1k of videos I sell more photos (just 300) in AS and SS... Would I to delete them???

« Reply #8 on: November 18, 2017, 03:34 »
0
Different story for me.
I was only doing video and I was doing fine with Fotolia: I had not a lot, but my regular 10-15 uploads per month, average $28 each, but sometimes the odd $70, let's say 400-600 per month.
not really increasing, in spite of constant uploading, but it was OK.
Then I had the stupid idea of starting to upload also photo (about 3 months ago)...
Guess what, I still had the same number of uploads, but they were all photos, fro ridiculous amounts, so my income went from $400-600 a month o some stupid $10-15 from one day to the next.
So this week I went like crazy deleting all my photo portfolio, one by one, and guess what?
I finally had a video sale yesterday and another one today
That is my experience, but yours maybe different.
Let us know how you get on, but if you are mainly a videographer, stay away from photo: they are at best a waste of time and can also hurt your video sales

I readed already this topic, and I am worry about it, I am a video principally, but I also uploaded some photos, an even having more than 1k of videos I sell more photos (just 300) in AS and SS... Would I to delete them???

« Reply #9 on: November 18, 2017, 03:35 »
0
That is my experience, but yours maybe different.
Let us know how you get on, but if you are mainly a videographer, stay away from photo: they are at best a waste of time and can also hurt your video sales

« Reply #10 on: November 18, 2017, 05:41 »
0
The short answer is no, I don't, but you want to compare this November with last November, not with October 2017.

That's fair enough, I agree.

While it remains to be seen how the full month of November will compare to previous years when the month is closed, based on the current status (18 days of the month) I'm down 50% compared to the same period of 18 days in November 2016 and down 65% compared to 18 days in November 2015. Needless to say, that my port increased substantially over the same time, and that I didn't do anything unorthodox just overnight (e.g. uploading different type of assets, or deleting large chunk of photos, etc.) to potentially cause such a disturbance to my performance. With less than 10 working days remaining (or even more due to looming holidays as mentioned here), I can be certain than my November 2017 will be very very much down compared to the same period of the last two years.

This looks very similar to what the SS did in April this year when a lot of people including myself saw a drastic fall in sales just overnight (my sales levels got to pre-April 2017 just recently). And similar to what IS/Getty did sometime this summer when they reshuffled the database to put new and newer images on top of search, making all others (including myself) who didn't upload in while (for good reasons) just miserable (a fall of more that 50%).

I just somehow thought that Fotolia/Adobe Stock wouldn't go into that extreme...

Uncle Pete

  • Great Place by a Great Lake - My Home Port
« Reply #11 on: November 19, 2017, 10:20 »
+5
Agencies boost new images because buyers want fresh material and new images, not the same old shots that have been up front for 10 years. It brings variety and diversity to the buyers. Doesn't that make sense from and agency or buyers viewpoint?

« Reply #12 on: November 19, 2017, 10:35 »
0
And similar to what IS/Getty did sometime this summer when they reshuffled the database to put new and newer images on top of search, making all others (including myself) who didn't upload in while (for good reasons) just miserable (a fall of more that 50%).

I just somehow thought that Fotolia/Adobe Stock wouldn't go into that extreme...

Extreme? What?

That is how all businesses do it. For a good reason.

New products + proven bestsellers. The ratio may vary.

« Reply #13 on: November 19, 2017, 11:01 »
0
Normal looking for me too. How much in number of dls or $ are we talking here?
If you only make a couple of hundred dollars or less/ month you are going to see big fluctuations like this.

« Reply #14 on: November 19, 2017, 11:25 »
0
.

« Reply #15 on: November 19, 2017, 16:18 »
0
On track for another BME for me, overtaking the previous one set in August.

« Reply #16 on: November 19, 2017, 16:41 »
0
If you only make a couple of hundred dollars or less/ month you are going to see big fluctuations like this.

Can you please explain why would there be less fluctuations be it any other level of revenue (dozens of dollars or thousands of dollars)?

With a certain level of revenue at FT being almost stable for the last 2.5 years (my case), the drop in sales this month that I mentioned in my previous post is unprecedented to me, hence I started this thread to see if anybody else experiences this (so far I haven't felt it is the same for a lot of you).

« Reply #17 on: November 19, 2017, 23:51 »
+3
Because the smaller the data set the more random fluctuation in percentage terms you will see. If you sold an average of 1 licenses a day you would see 100% variations a day all the time.  If you sell 10 a day less variation but still a lot more than if you sold 1000 a day.

« Reply #18 on: November 19, 2017, 23:56 »
+2
Look at your April vs May vs July for example. Looks like 50% swings are not unusual for you at all actually. Doesn't the hollow chart indicate stock performer predicts a pretty standard November for you by the end anyway? (I don't use it anymore but if I remember rightly that is what that bar is supposed to be right?)

« Reply #19 on: November 20, 2017, 02:20 »
+1
I also experience drop in sales and earnings this month, maybe not as huge as yours.

derek

    This user is banned.
« Reply #20 on: November 20, 2017, 02:27 »
+4
Was doing excellent with old FT as an Emerald rank until Adobe took over. It went right down!....One would have thought that with the huge name of Adobe takings would just sky-rockett for everybody but not so. The opposite really.
« Last Edit: November 21, 2017, 02:10 by derek »

« Reply #21 on: November 20, 2017, 15:36 »
0
Look at your April vs May vs July for example. Looks like 50% swings are not unusual for you at all actually. Doesn't the hollow chart indicate stock performer predicts a pretty standard November for you by the end anyway? (I don't use it anymore but if I remember rightly that is what that bar is supposed to be right?)

Thanks. Sure, there are swings, likes everywhere else, my case with FT is not exception. The question is how much of a swing do you have. My average downward swing (i.e. a fall in % compared to previous month) is 25%, with the biggest so far being -50% (which happened during my third month of sales at FT when things were not stable with port increase etc.) I estimate that November 2017 will see a 70-80% drop (currently -76% to October 2017, with 8 working days remaining, some of them being public holidays). Isn't too much of a swing?

And the hollow chart indeed is a prediction by StockPerformer for the month, but I'm not aware of its algorithm (how they update it), and I can tell you that that hollow bar will stay very close to the filled dark bar you saw in my original post based on the performance up-to-date. It just doesn't fill up to honor what StockPerformer predicts now.

« Reply #22 on: November 21, 2017, 01:50 »
0
FT/AS is the only agency that keeps my average sales on Novembrer, SS and IS are in a really deep drop down.

« Reply #23 on: November 21, 2017, 09:43 »
0
focolai is completely dead for me. i cannot understand what sell there. every agency is doing good even dreamstime seems to recover this month. fotolia zero.

derek

    This user is banned.
« Reply #24 on: November 21, 2017, 12:56 »
+1
Jonbull!  I havent got a clue and dont really care but rumor has it that they have broken the search ( happened to IS some years back) for those who remember!...IS was never the same after that and everything went wrong!

As I said this is what I've heard from a couple of sources but dont take my word for it. In any case Adobe is hardly movimng at all!

« Reply #25 on: November 21, 2017, 13:24 »
0
I know how some of you hate this kind of topics, but this one appears to be out of an ordinary one (at least for me), and I'm on a verge of freaking out: my sales at Fotolia/Adobe Stock have almost stopped in November, with a projected drop in sales vs October by -20% (or considerably more if the trend remains) and could be my worst ever month in 2.5 years (port of close to 2K images). As you can see, in my case fluctuations month to month with FT/AS are common, but November is something special (remember, we're in 17 November, with less than 10 working days left in this month).

Capture" border="0

Does anybody have a similar situation?


Don't worry or think too much ;D

« Reply #26 on: November 23, 2017, 12:09 »
+1
After a good October, November has been poor to say the least. The stability their search engine once had seems to have gone. SS went through a period when there search was radically changing every couple of weeks. Their's seems to have stabilised to a degree while FT AS has taken the same characteristics as the old (bad) SS search. Makes me wonder if that has something to do with Scott being over there now. Either way, it's no where near as good as it once was.

« Reply #27 on: November 24, 2017, 03:12 »
+2
After a good October, November has been poor to say the least. The stability their search engine once had seems to have gone. SS went through a period when there search was radically changing every couple of weeks. Their's seems to have stabilised to a degree while FT AS has taken the same characteristics as the old (bad) SS search. Makes me wonder if that has something to do with Scott being over there now. Either way, it's no where near as good as it once was.
Agree I thought things were back to "normal" but plummeting down the rankings again...might still be an OK month but I now experience periods of total inactivity on there which I never really came across before.

derek

    This user is banned.
« Reply #28 on: November 24, 2017, 04:10 »
0
After a good October, November has been poor to say the least. The stability their search engine once had seems to have gone. SS went through a period when there search was radically changing every couple of weeks. Their's seems to have stabilised to a degree while FT AS has taken the same characteristics as the old (bad) SS search. Makes me wonder if that has something to do with Scott being over there now. Either way, it's no where near as good as it once was.

Yeah well why do you think they hired Scott??  hohoho!  in any event the search at the moment is really bad. It surprises me when Adobe is such a fantastic programming/software corp. If theres anything that should be spot on its the search. Also many suppliers feel they are getting blocked for hours on end. My future there is bleak its gone from my second best agency to number 5.
I havent got the time anymore supplying agencies that cant produce an output according to my input. I'll give Ft and Dt until new year?

« Reply #29 on: November 24, 2017, 06:47 »
+1
Just looked at % of US sales to the rest of the world. I'm routinely over 90% US sales, often 95-98% even though I supply work that is not specific to the US (I'm based in the UK). It's like my port is not visible anywhere else other than the US. It certainly explains why my sales plummet when the US has a holiday. The last couple of days have been terrible yet SS is good. They seem to have a good balance of visibility across all countries.

It just seems that they've badly broken the search at the moment. My weekly position dropped massively to 700 this week, lowest it's been for years!

Good news is that good sales came in from Archangel.... 4 sales = 1.5x FT monthly earnings! I'm thinking of just focusing on them and other RM agencies now and send quick and simple stuff to micro.

« Reply #30 on: November 25, 2017, 03:59 »
0
same here 90% us sales (-30% tax) - before AS it was 10% us sales - and I m on eu fotolia - strange?!!! - and sales a down...

« Reply #31 on: November 25, 2017, 04:32 »
+1
same here 90% us sales (-30% tax) - before AS it was 10% us sales - and I m on eu fotolia - strange?!!! - and sales a down...

What does "eu fotolia" have to do with anything?

The reason US sales have increased is because of Adobe. A US company with a huge US market.

« Reply #32 on: November 25, 2017, 04:58 »
+1
Even after AS took over, US sales were still 30-50%. What is odd now is the complete lack of ANY non us sales. It feels like the search, which is likely to have some form of geo feature (as is often used), maybe out of balance.

There was a point when it was the other way round, minimal US sales and it had similar results. Long spells without sales until the priority country/ continent woke back up for work. What we are seeing is a tweak to the search that has created an imbalance of geo exposure.


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk Pro

« Reply #33 on: November 25, 2017, 05:05 »
+1
For the first time I just checked my percentage of sales in the US.
And yes, 100% of sales this month come from the US.
A big zero from Europe, while I am based in the UK and in the past I always found that Fotolia used to be very friendly to European content.
Go fugure

« Reply #34 on: November 25, 2017, 05:52 »
+2
For the first time I just checked my percentage of sales in the US.
And yes, 100% of sales this month come from the US.
A big zero from Europe, while I am based in the UK and in the past I always found that Fotolia used to be very friendly to European content.
Go fugure
Similar for me and used to get mostly non-us sales...something seems wrong here.

« Reply #35 on: November 25, 2017, 08:28 »
0
For those experiencing the same pattern, report it to FT via the message system. Ive already done this with a copy of last months percentages. It could be something they are not aware of so its worth reporting it so they know to investigate it!


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk Pro

« Reply #36 on: November 25, 2017, 08:39 »
0
THere is the strong possibility that it is simply the statistic in FT about US sales that is not working anymore.
Same goes with views in FT: it is all over the place

« Reply #37 on: November 25, 2017, 11:49 »
+2
Same experience here. I wrote this about a month ago in some other topic.

Well, I think they totally neglected EU buyers. I used to get a lot of credit sales XL, L, M, now, very rarely. EL sales were more frequent year ago also. Also, most of my 0.99 sales are coming from US, and those sales are my mostly main income + subs. So, I think US sales increased, but EU sales dropped significally.

« Reply #38 on: November 25, 2017, 12:25 »
+1
The sales reporting is fine. Im heading toward my BME at FT/AS. Check your weekly rankings to see if where you are compared to previous weeks. If you didnt have any Thanksgiving content, sales will mostly go down for you a bit during the last half of November.

« Reply #39 on: November 25, 2017, 20:53 »
0
I just went to check my stats and for November so far, my non-US sales are 24%

For Oct 2017 it was 20% non-US. I'm based in the US.

In the thread about this last month I had noted my recent average over the last (almost) year was 29% non-US. As I noted in that thread, that is down a lot from earlier days.

« Reply #40 on: November 26, 2017, 02:43 »
0
The sales reporting is fine. Im heading toward my BME at FT/AS. Check your weekly rankings to see if where you are compared to previous weeks. If you didnt have any Thanksgiving content, sales will mostly go down for you a bit during the last half of November.
A BIT mine have tanked I expected a bit of a downturn but anyway these things happen....but FT is much more or a roller coaster for me the last few months.....still likely to make a decent month as the first half was smokin' but disconcerting when you are plummeting down the rankings!

« Reply #41 on: November 26, 2017, 06:55 »
0
Fotolia and Storyblocks are dead in november! >:(

« Reply #42 on: November 26, 2017, 10:03 »
+4
The sales reporting is fine. Im heading toward my BME at FT/AS. Check your weekly rankings to see if where you are compared to previous weeks. If you didnt have any Thanksgiving content, sales will mostly go down for you a bit during the last half of November.
What has Thanksgiving to do with this? It is a US and Canadian celebration, how can that affect EU buyers and contributors. There is a big world out there.

I have no Thanksgiving images and my sales are just a bit down from last month but we still have a few days.
Also, I have 68.66% US sales (in commission). For a better comparison, we should have access to the number of downloads too for those US sales not just the credits (without counting them one by one).
« Last Edit: November 26, 2017, 10:10 by Dodie »

« Reply #43 on: November 27, 2017, 02:42 »
+2
What has Thanksgiving to do with this? It is a US and Canadian celebration, how can that affect EU buyers and contributors. There is a big world out there.

I have no Thanksgiving images and my sales are just a bit down from last month but we still have a few days.
Also, I have 68.66% US sales (in commission). For a better comparison, we should have access to the number of downloads too for those US sales not just the credits (without counting them one by one).

Like you said, the US market makes up nearly 70% of your sales. On some days, the US market makes up over 90% of my sales. If the biggest market is on holiday, it would only make sense if the sales are down from the previous month.

niktol

« Reply #44 on: November 27, 2017, 09:46 »
0
The sales reporting is fine. Im heading toward my BME at FT/AS. Check your weekly rankings to see if where you are compared to previous weeks. If you didnt have any Thanksgiving content, sales will mostly go down for you a bit during the last half of November.
What has Thanksgiving to do with this? It is a US and Canadian celebration, how can that affect EU buyers and contributors. There is a big world out there.



Not a Canadian, the Canadian was in October. About half of my sales is in the US, so while the US holidays do not affect the sales as much as Saturdays, but I can definitely feel the difference.

« Reply #45 on: November 27, 2017, 11:26 »
+1
What has Thanksgiving to do with this? It is a US and Canadian celebration, how can that affect EU buyers and contributors. There is a big world out there.

I have no Thanksgiving images and my sales are just a bit down from last month but we still have a few days.
Also, I have 68.66% US sales (in commission). For a better comparison, we should have access to the number of downloads too for those US sales not just the credits (without counting them one by one).
Like you said, the US market makes up nearly 70% of your sales. On some days, the US market makes up over 90% of my sales. If the biggest market is on holiday, it would only make sense if the sales are down from the previous month.
US holiday or not, I was asking where are the sale from the rest of the world? Or why are they missing?
SS is an US company too and I have sales from all over the world but hardly ever from North America.


« Last Edit: November 27, 2017, 11:29 by Dodie »

« Reply #46 on: November 27, 2017, 12:07 »
+2
What has Thanksgiving to do with this? It is a US and Canadian celebration, how can that affect EU buyers and contributors. There is a big world out there.

I have no Thanksgiving images and my sales are just a bit down from last month but we still have a few days.
Also, I have 68.66% US sales (in commission). For a better comparison, we should have access to the number of downloads too for those US sales not just the credits (without counting them one by one).
Like you said, the US market makes up nearly 70% of your sales. On some days, the US market makes up over 90% of my sales. If the biggest market is on holiday, it would only make sense if the sales are down from the previous month.
US holiday or not, I was asking where are the sale from the rest of the world? Or why are they missing?
SS is an US company too and I have sales from all over the world but hardly ever from North America.

Speculation, but it could be an accounting change rather than a change in the demographics of sales.  For example sales through Adobe products maybe reported as US sales and not where the buyer is from, if Adobe products are considered a partner for accounting purposes.

« Reply #47 on: November 27, 2017, 12:45 »
+1
What has Thanksgiving to do with this? It is a US and Canadian celebration, how can that affect EU buyers and contributors. There is a big world out there.

I have no Thanksgiving images and my sales are just a bit down from last month but we still have a few days.
Also, I have 68.66% US sales (in commission). For a better comparison, we should have access to the number of downloads too for those US sales not just the credits (without counting them one by one).
Like you said, the US market makes up nearly 70% of your sales. On some days, the US market makes up over 90% of my sales. If the biggest market is on holiday, it would only make sense if the sales are down from the previous month.
US holiday or not, I was asking where are the sale from the rest of the world? Or why are they missing?
SS is an US company too and I have sales from all over the world but hardly ever from North America.

Speculation, but it could be an accounting change rather than a change in the demographics of sales.  For example sales through Adobe products maybe reported as US sales and not where the buyer is from, if Adobe products are considered a partner for accounting purposes.
That could be an explanation. It never crossed my mind but possible.

« Reply #48 on: November 27, 2017, 14:55 »
+1
What has Thanksgiving to do with this? It is a US and Canadian celebration, how can that affect EU buyers and contributors. There is a big world out there.

I have no Thanksgiving images and my sales are just a bit down from last month but we still have a few days.
Also, I have 68.66% US sales (in commission). For a better comparison, we should have access to the number of downloads too for those US sales not just the credits (without counting them one by one).

Like you said, the US market makes up nearly 70% of your sales. On some days, the US market makes up over 90% of my sales. If the biggest market is on holiday, it would only make sense if the sales are down from the previous month.

A lot "US sales" here, too (whatever that means)
Here is the trend of my US earning percentage for the past few years:

« Reply #49 on: November 27, 2017, 16:25 »
+1
What has Thanksgiving to do with this? It is a US and Canadian celebration, how can that affect EU buyers and contributors. There is a big world out there.

I have no Thanksgiving images and my sales are just a bit down from last month but we still have a few days.
Also, I have 68.66% US sales (in commission). For a better comparison, we should have access to the number of downloads too for those US sales not just the credits (without counting them one by one).

Like you said, the US market makes up nearly 70% of your sales. On some days, the US market makes up over 90% of my sales. If the biggest market is on holiday, it would only make sense if the sales are down from the previous month.

A lot "US sales" here, too (whatever that means)
Here is the trend of my US earning percentage for the past few years:

You would be pissed if you were paying 30% withholding tax.

« Reply #50 on: November 28, 2017, 03:59 »
+1
What has Thanksgiving to do with this? It is a US and Canadian celebration, how can that affect EU buyers and contributors. There is a big world out there.

I have no Thanksgiving images and my sales are just a bit down from last month but we still have a few days.
Also, I have 68.66% US sales (in commission). For a better comparison, we should have access to the number of downloads too for those US sales not just the credits (without counting them one by one).

Like you said, the US market makes up nearly 70% of your sales. On some days, the US market makes up over 90% of my sales. If the biggest market is on holiday, it would only make sense if the sales are down from the previous month.

A lot "US sales" here, too (whatever that means)
Here is the trend of my US earning percentage for the past few years:

You would be pissed if you were paying 30% withholding tax.


I am pissed - no way that my 90% of sales are from us - something is wrong - and they take 30% of 90% of my sales - before AS I had 10% us sales - what happened with no us sales - something is deeply wrong here!!!!..... and unlike other  agencies, they don t send tax forms
« Last Edit: November 28, 2017, 04:07 by ferdinand »

« Reply #51 on: November 30, 2017, 14:06 »
0
What has Thanksgiving to do with this? It is a US and Canadian celebration, how can that affect EU buyers and contributors. There is a big world out there.

I have no Thanksgiving images and my sales are just a bit down from last month but we still have a few days.
Also, I have 68.66% US sales (in commission). For a better comparison, we should have access to the number of downloads too for those US sales not just the credits (without counting them one by one).

Like you said, the US market makes up nearly 70% of your sales. On some days, the US market makes up over 90% of my sales. If the biggest market is on holiday, it would only make sense if the sales are down from the previous month.

A lot "US sales" here, too (whatever that means)
Here is the trend of my US earning percentage for the past few years:

You would be pissed if you were paying 30% withholding tax.


I am pissed - no way that my 90% of sales are from us - something is wrong - and they take 30% of 90% of my sales - before AS I had 10% us sales - what happened with no us sales - something is deeply wrong here!!!!..... and unlike other  agencies, they don t send tax forms

Looks like you are on your own with this one, which is a surprise maybe the wrong thread, try reaching out to Matt and hit on him at mhayward@adobe.com

« Reply #52 on: November 30, 2017, 14:31 »
0
What has Thanksgiving to do with this? It is a US and Canadian celebration, how can that affect EU buyers and contributors. There is a big world out there.

I have no Thanksgiving images and my sales are just a bit down from last month but we still have a few days.
Also, I have 68.66% US sales (in commission). For a better comparison, we should have access to the number of downloads too for those US sales not just the credits (without counting them one by one).

Like you said, the US market makes up nearly 70% of your sales. On some days, the US market makes up over 90% of my sales. If the biggest market is on holiday, it would only make sense if the sales are down from the previous month.

A lot "US sales" here, too (whatever that means)
Here is the trend of my US earning percentage for the past few years:

You would be pissed if you were paying 30% withholding tax.


I am pissed - no way that my 90% of sales are from us - something is wrong - and they take 30% of 90% of my sales - before AS I had 10% us sales - what happened with no us sales - something is deeply wrong here!!!!..... and unlike other  agencies, they don t send tax forms

Doesn't your country have a double taxation avoidance treaty with US?
What is the level of taxes you have to pay in your country? Is it less than 30%?

Edit: If I'm not wrong, you are from Portugal and you have a tax treaty with US: https://www.congress.gov/congressional-report/104th-congress/executive-report/8/1
Taxation in Portugal is higher than 30% for income levels above 20K, anyway. Am I wrong?
« Last Edit: November 30, 2017, 14:36 by Zero Talent »


 

Related Topics

  Subject / Started by Replies Last post
21 Replies
7012 Views
Last post April 08, 2007, 22:10
by litifeta
19 Replies
10823 Views
Last post October 17, 2009, 02:18
by RacePhoto
10 Replies
5115 Views
Last post June 09, 2012, 09:00
by franky242
7 Replies
2101 Views
Last post September 14, 2012, 09:17
by ruigsantos
5 Replies
1941 Views
Last post May 05, 2017, 05:25
by max headroom

Sponsors

Microstock Poll Results