Would you use any of these for the IS application, if so which one(s)?

http://www.ltsw.com/public/ExtremeDeerCrossingSign.jpg

http://www.ltsw.com/public/FireDangerWarningSign.jpg

http://www.ltsw.com/public/Interstate40signonbluecloudysky.jpg

http://www.ltsw.com/public/Route66signonbluesky.jpg

Not sure if you can do editorial on the app or not, if not then #2 won't work.
I like #3 a lot, but I think I like 4 more.
I think the #1 is really good but #4 is the best one and would work for the application, if you think otherwise please let me know and why.

#1 don�t see what can a reviewer like in it.. there just a gorgeous blue sky..
#2 trademark for sure..
#3 not in focus and far from focus
#4 not tack sharp (I would shoot again there but a kind of 3/4 of the sign and the other 1/4 with blue sky, and a little on the side (not front)

this last #4 has a lot of sensor spots on it really close to the sign (left and up)

shoot "girl/boy" again

#1 don�t see what can a reviewer like in it.. there just a gorgeous blue sky..
#2 trademark for sure..
#3 not in focus and far from focus
#4 not tack sharp (I would shoot again there but a kind of 3/4 of the sign and the other 1/4 with blue sky, and a little on the side (not front)

this last #4 has a lot of sensor spots on it really close to the sign (left and up)

shoot "girl/boy" again

Yeah, I saw the sensor spots too.  First I thought they might be on the lens, then the filter, finally the senso.  Did the auto-clean that, that didn't work.  Just spent 2 hours clean, test, clean, test...  Finally, I think I got it.  Need to re-shoot 3 and 4.  So are we saying Smokey can't be submitted for the application?

Thanks all.

Quote from: luissantos84 on May 29, 2011, 15:25

#1 don�t see what can a reviewer like in it.. there just a gorgeous blue sky..
#2 trademark for sure..
#3 not in focus and far from focus
#4 not tack sharp (I would shoot again there but a kind of 3/4 of the sign and the other 1/4 with blue sky, and a little on the side (not front)

this last #4 has a lot of sensor spots on it really close to the sign (left and up)

shoot "girl/boy" again

Yeah, I saw the sensor spots too.  First I thought they might be on the lens, then the filter, finally the senso.  Did the auto-clean that, that didn't work.  Just spent 2 hours clean, test, clean, test...  Finally, I think I got it.  Need to re-shoot 3 and 4.  So are we saying Smokey can't be submitted for the application?

Thanks all.

guess not, I don�t know Smokey but sure it was design by someone.. really don�t know