I'm sorry but Magnum's post smacks of jealousy.  Calling out somebody else's work is low and very unprofessional.  Truth is, it's a great shot and if you spend time looking at the rest of her portfolio, her work is solid across the board.  If I were a buyer, I'd grab her stuff like a kid grabs candy.

Sure, there are times when I wonder why an image is so popular but, as stated, the customer is always right.  There are times I think that the image is badly done or could use improvement.  But I would never, ever say anything (unless I'm their teacher).  This type of behavior reminds me of how teenage girls are in high school.  When they see a pretty girl, they start talking trash about her behind her back.  They end up looking like idiots for doing so.

Sorry Magnum but I think you crossed the line.  You need to focus on your own work and stop calling other people out on what's "wrong" with their work.  If the creator of that image showed up here, I'm sure she would be hurt that you essentially trashed an image she may be incredibly proud of (and should be!).

Marj out!